When everything is a priority, the team decides on its own what to do

When everything comes in as urgent, nobody goes without a priority: each person picks their own. Why urgent always wins, and how to agree on an order.

A clay balance scale with two pans, in light blue, lilac and purple, with a small orange ball on top, over a dark background

Almost every guide on how to prioritize tasks is about one person alone with their own list. On a team, the problem is different: when everything comes in as urgent, nobody goes without a priority. Each person picks their own, by whatever criterion is at hand, and the sum of those choices is rarely the order the company needed.

When everything is urgent, each person decides their own way

Without an agreed, visible order, the team doesn't stop: it prioritizes on its own. Look at the criteria that show up when nobody says what comes first:

  • the request from whoever pushed loudest or most recently;
  • whatever just landed in the team group chat;
  • the quickest thing to finish, because it feels like a productive day;
  • the client who called, even if another client will cost more;
  • whatever the person enjoys doing.

Picture an ordinary Tuesday. Sales wants a proposal yesterday, finance needs the monthly report and a client complains in the group chat. Three people on the team make three different choices, and none of them is wrong by the criterion of whoever chose.

Together, those criteria pull the team in five directions. By the end of the week, everyone has worked hard, and the task that mattered most is still sitting there.

Why urgent always wins

Urgency has a pull of its own, and it wins even when it's worth less. The idea is old. In a 1954 speech, Dwight Eisenhower quoted a former college president who split problems into two kinds, the urgent and the important, and said the urgent are not important and the important are never urgent. The matrix that crosses urgent and important ended up carrying Eisenhower's name.

More recent research shows the downside. In five experiments published in the Journal of Consumer Research in 2018, Meng Zhu, Yang Yang and Christopher Hsee saw people choose tasks that paid less just because they seemed to have a short deadline. A false sense that the task was about to expire was enough.

On a team, that means the important task without a tight deadline tends to lose. The routine nobody chases, as the post on recurring tasks shows, is the first one pushed to later.

How to prioritize tasks as a team

Prioritizing as a team means agreeing on an order and keeping it where everyone can see it. The urgent-and-important matrix helps you think, but the decision only counts once it becomes a queue the whole team can see. One way to do it:

  1. Put everything in one team list. Priorities hidden in messages, emails or someone's head don't count. The same goes for invisible work, which weighs so much precisely because it isn't on any list.
  2. Put it in order. What's at the top comes first, period. No ties, no three "top priorities".
  3. Only set deadlines on what really has one. Made-up deadlines meant to hurry people teach the team to ignore every deadline.
  4. Agree on who changes the order and when. For example: the queue gets reviewed on Monday, and a new urgent item goes to the top with the reason written down.
  5. Everyone works from the top down. Whoever finishes doesn't ask what to do next, they look at the list.

Order also helps you say no. When something new and urgent goes to the top, something else moves down, and everyone sees what moved. That's the conversation priorities hidden in the group chat never force you to have.

The good side effect is that the manager steps out of the middle. Nobody needs to ask what comes first, and the manager stops being the team's bottleneck.

The list order becomes the team's agreement

In Experto, the order of open tasks is the same for everyone who sees the list: what's at the top comes first. To change it, just drag the task, or use Alt+↑ and Alt+↓ on the keyboard (Option on a Mac). A new task created in New item goes to the top, and everything else moves down right away, for everyone.

From there, the work carries on in the list itself:

  • Everyone pulls the next one: whoever is going to work on it pulls the task at the top, and the team sees who has it. The post on how to split tasks without anyone handing them out walks through it step by step.
  • The week is in plain sight: in the Organizer, lists sit side by side and the calendar shows each task on its day, as in the post on how to plan your team's week.
  • Delays show up on their own: a task past its deadline turns red, and the Organizer's When › Overdue filter gathers them all.
  • Routines get a place in the queue: with a list connected to itself, a recurring task comes back open with its next deadline, without depending on anyone's memory.

Frequently asked questions

How do you prioritize tasks when everything is urgent?

Put everything in one team list and put it in order, with no ties. Ask which task is worth the most if you could only do one, and put that one at the top. The rest follows the queue.

What is the Eisenhower matrix?

It's a way to sort tasks into four groups by crossing what's urgent with what's important. It helps you think, but on a team it only works once it turns into an order everyone can see.

Who sets the team's priorities?

Whoever manages the team agrees on the order with everyone, ideally at a fixed time each week. After that, the list shows the priority, and each person takes the next task without having to ask.

Want to see the whole team working in the same order? Create your free account, free forever for up to 2 members, and find out how to prioritize tasks with a list everyone can see.

Share

Start collaborating with your team!

Free forever, up to 2 members

Related content